Relative perception in the Wnt pathway

rocks-in-balanceHere is an idea we are very ardently pursuing in the lab.

In multicellular animals, cells constantly signal with one another to coordinate function.  About twenty or so signaling pathways have been identified so far. Each signaling pathway consists of a network of dozens of interacting proteins. How do these pathways transduce signal from outside into specific responses inside the cells?  How is information propagated?  When we set out to ask these questions, we found that another question had to be asked first:  What is the information that the cells sense?

Our work in the Wnt signaling pathway led to a tantalizing suggestion: the cells sense signal in a relative manner.  The information that the cells sense in the Wnt pathway is not the absolute level of the signal, but instead the cells sense changes in the level of the signal.  Specifically, it is the fold-change in the signal that appears to be important in the Wnt pathway (Goentoro and Kirschner 2009; Goentoro et al., 2009; Shoval et al., 2010).

Why does it matter whether signaling is relative or absolute?  It leads to different models for how signaling works.  Relative sensing means that the cells are continually adjusting signal detection to background or basal signal level.  This may help explain how signaling works in the face of variation from cell to cell.  Relative sensing may help explain how the Wnt pathway can function in many contexts, in spite of variation across tissues.  Relative sensing helps maintain sensitivity during repeated signal, when cells may not have enough time to return to the basal state.

Weber’s Law in cell signaling.  Relative sensing in cell signaling brings to mind the way our sensory system works.  We perceive our world in a relative manner.  Our sensory system continually adjusts signal detection to background.  To understand this, imagine how we can easily talk to each other in a quiet room, but we have to shout a bit in a lively market.  The relative nature of our sensory system was described about 150 years ago in what is now know as the Weber’s Law:

Detectable Signal / Background = Constant

Weber’s Law has also been observed in bacterial chemotaxis and phototropism in phycomyces (Delbruck and Reichardt, 1956).  We may be seeing convergence between information processing at the organism, tissue, and cell level.

The psychophycisist Ernst H. Weber studied the relative nature of our perception, and formulated it into the famous Weber’s Law in 1850s. Image source:

Ernst H. Weber. Image source:

Might Weber’s Law be a more general principle in cell signaling?  Work by Celina Cohen-Saidon in Uri Alon’s lab suggests that signaling in the EGF/MAPK pathway may also follow Weber’s Law.  Moreover, we recently found evidence for Weber’s Law in another major signaling pathway.  Stay tuned as we follow up on this exciting lead!

Mechanism of Weber’s Law in cell signaling.  What is the mechanism for Weber’s Law detection in the Wnt pathway? Sensing fold-changes in signal level means that cells remember the level of signal from the past, and take the ratio between the present and past level of signal.  We are now deep in biochemical purification to identify the molecules that serve as the memory in the Wnt pathway and mediate fold-change computation.

Kardiermaschine. Photograph by massenpunkt.

Kardiermaschine. Photograph by massenpunkt.